Skip navigation Search or ask a question     Create   Avatar image Cheap STIHL HS 45 vs PRO STIHL HS 82 T — Is It Worth Paying More?!

Cheap STIHL HS 45 vs PRO STIHL HS 82 T — Is It Worth Paying More?!

Written by: Mary Clementi

|

Published on

|

Time to read 7 min

STIHL HS 45 vs. HS 82 T: Hedge Trimmer Comparison

The STIHL HS 82 T felt like a major upgrade over the HS 45 in comfort, reach, and build quality, but the difference in the finished cut was smaller than we expected. The lower-priced HS 45 still cut well, so the extra money mainly bought us a smoother working experience.

If you're choosing between these two gas-powered hedge trimmers, that distinction matters. We compared their features, then cut several types of growth to see how those differences felt in use.

STIHL HS 45 vs. HS 82 T at a Glance

We put the homeowner-focused STIHL HS 45 hedge trimmer against the fully commercial STIHL HS 82 T. The HS 45 we showed was made in STIHL's Chinese plant, while the HS 82 T was made in its German plant.

These are the prices and specifications we discussed during the comparison.

Feature

STIHL HS 45

STIHL HS 82 T

Price quoted

$379

$729

Blade length tested

18 inches

24 inches

Sharpened cutting edges described

Four

Eight

Stroke rate quoted

3,700 strokes per minute

5,100 strokes per minute

Rear handle

Fixed

Swiveling

Vibration control

Springs and isolators

More extensive anti-vibration system

Gearbox construction observed

Steel-plate gearbox cover

Cast gearbox housing

Exhaust direction

Out the bottom

Out the front

At nearly twice the price, the HS 82 T needed to offer more than a longer blade. Its controls, vibration isolation, and cutting feel were the bigger reasons it stood apart.

Longer Blades and a Higher Stroke Rate

The HS 45's 18-inch blade was noticeably shorter than the 24-inch blade on our HS 82 T. A 30-inch version of the HS 82 T was also available.

That extra reach mattered once we started working across the hedges. With the shorter blade, we had to extend our arms farther and spend more time reaching for growth.

We also pointed out the difference in the blade setups: four sharpened cutting edges on the HS 45 versus eight on the HS 82 T.

The HS 82 T's 5,100-stroke-per-minute rate was another substantial jump over the 3,700 strokes per minute we quoted for the HS 45. During the comparison, we described the HS 82 T as having the highest stroke rate available from any hedge trimmer maker.

Handle, Starting, and Gearbox Differences

A swiveling handle made side cuts more comfortable

The HS 82 T's rear handle swivels, so we could keep a comfortable grip while cutting down the sides of a hedge.

The HS 45 has a fixed handle. We could still make those cuts, but we had to get comfortable operating the trigger with a thumb or a different finger as we changed position. We didn't find that unworkable; it simply wasn't as comfortable.

The HS 45's on/off switch also caught us out. It didn't stay in the on position, and we tried pulling the starter a couple of times while the switch was off.

The HS 82 T felt more substantial

Looking underneath the machines showed another clear difference. The HS 82 T had a cast gearbox housing and directed its exhaust out the front, away from the operator. The HS 45 had a steel-plate gearbox cover and discharged exhaust underneath.

The HS 82 T's starter also felt easier to pull. In contrast, the HS 45 had more resistance and lacked the same smooth starting feel.

Those details shaped our impression that the commercial machine was better built. We expected it to last longer, although this comparison wasn't a long-term durability test.

How the HS 82 T Cut Through the Hedges

The HS 82 T felt fast and smooth as soon as we started cutting. We could move along the hedge with almost no sense of resistance, and we felt no vibration in our fingers.

We nearly finished the first hedge in one pass. To get the surface looking right, we went back over it once more.

The description we kept coming back to was a "lightsaber." Nothing seemed to grab or interrupt the cut; the blade floated through the growth.

The HS 82 T felt almost effortless through the hedge, but that also meant a mistaken cut could remove a lot before we corrected it.

That smoothness gave the machine a luxury feel. However, we still needed to compare it with the HS 45 on similar growth before deciding how much of an advantage showed up in the finished hedge.

How the HS 45 Performed

We were happy with the HS 45's cut. It handled the hedge better than its lower price might suggest, and its lighter weight was an immediate positive.

The shorter blade was the main cutting limitation. We couldn't reach as far, so covering the hedge took longer and required more stretching.

Noise and vibration were much more noticeable. Although the HS 45 has springs and isolators, we felt considerably more vibration through our hands. Our fingertips started tingling during use.

It also sounded louder. One of us had ringing ears afterward, which prompted our comment about hearing protection.

Even with those drawbacks, we liked the machine. It was a capable little hedge trimmer, and the quality of its cut kept it in the comparison.

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet consectetur

We didn't want to judge both machines on a single hedge. One plant had especially flexible limbs, which made us curious about how the trimmers would handle growth that moved away from the blades.

We also noticed that the first two hedges weren't behaving identically. We may have cut deeper into one, or it may have received more light. On one side, we were catching more feathery outer leaves, while the other presented different, stickier growth.

Because those differences could affect the cutting feel, we moved to two similar southern red cedars and used one for each machine. Their wispier growth gave us a different comparison from the broader leaves of the earlier hedges.

For one of us, it was the first time trimming a southern red cedar. That part of the test was also a chance to learn how the plant responded, rather than treating every hedge as the same cutting job.

Guards Changed the Handling Feel

The HS 82 T's blade-tip guard was a small feature we appreciated during downward cuts. It extended beyond the cutting blades, so the guard could touch the ground or concrete before the blades did.

That stood out more to the shorter of us, particularly when working near ground level.

We also felt more comfortable with the orange guards on the HS 82 T. While shaping the cedar with the HS 45, the blade came near the operator's body often enough to make the difference noticeable.

Those were our handling impressions. We felt safer with the HS 82 T's guards present, rather than treating them as a guarantee against blade contact.

The Cut-Quality Gap Was Smaller Than the Comfort Gap

By the end, we could see a step up in cut quality with the HS 82 T. Both of us noticed it, but we agreed it wasn't a night-and-day difference.

The bigger separation was how the machines felt while producing that cut. The HS 82 T was quieter to our ears, smoother through the growth, and more comfortable to hold.

Our comparisons became a Corolla versus a Bentley, or a Casio versus a Rolex. Those analogies captured our impression of the build and finish: the less expensive machine did the job, while the commercial one felt much more refined.

The HS 45 cut well enough that the HS 82 T's strongest argument was comfort and handling, rather than a dramatically different finished hedge.

For someone getting into hedge trimming, we considered the HS 45 a good-value option. We also discussed it as a reasonable lower-cost choice for a crew likely to treat equipment roughly.

Other Hedge Trimmer Options Mentioned

We also pointed out that there were more choices beyond the two configurations we used.

The R model has larger teeth and different gearing for cutting bigger branches. A 30-inch version offers more blade length, too.

We mentioned a one-sided model with a 40-inch blade and a handle farther out along the machine. That layout was the option we discussed for reaching across deep hedges.

Those choices gave us more ways to match a trimmer to the work, rather than choosing only between the 18-inch HS 45 and the 24-inch HS 82 T shown in our comparison.


Finishing the Trees With the STIHL HLA 150

We also used the electric STIHL HLA 150 to finish the trees without getting on a ladder.

We described its head rate as 4,000 RPM and found it a delight to use. It was a separate tool from the two handheld gas trimmers, but it helped us finish the higher growth without climbing.


Final Verdict: Value or a Smoother Working Experience

We came away impressed with the HS 45's value. It was lighter and produced a good cut, although its shorter reach, noise, and vibration made it less comfortable.

The HS 82 T justified its higher price most clearly through comfort and handling. We noticed a better cut, but the strongest difference was how smoothly the machine worked while making it.