SureCan vs Regular Gas Cans: Is It Worth the Extra Money?

SureCan vs Regular Gas Cans: Is It Worth the Extra Money?

Written by: Mary Clementi

|

Published on

|

Time to read 6 min

Gas can frustrations are common—awkward angles, drips, and tight handles can make refueling a chore. The SureCan promises smoother pours and cleaner storage, but it costs more than your average can. Is the upgrade worth it for weekend warriors or daily users? Let’s look at how these cans measure up and which one makes the most sense for your garage.

"Ever spilled gas all over your feet, your tools, or even your lawnmower—just trying to fill up? Today, I’m breaking down SureCan versus regular gas cans. Is SureCan worth the extra cash, or should you stick with the basic jug? Let’s save you money—and a headache."

SureCan versus regular gas cans

SureCan vs. Regular Gas Cans: Is It Worth the Extra Money?

Is the SureCan really worth all the hype? With its innovative design, it's definitely caught the eye of many. But does it truly outperform standard gas cans, making it a worthwhile investment? We're diving deep into a comparison, looking at durability, ease of use, and flow rate, to help you decide if the SureCan is the right choice for you.

If you're curious about other lawn care equipment and products, be sure to check out Main Street Mower's website .

Gas Can Lineup: Meet the Contenders

Stu, who has years of experience dealing with gas cans, puts four different cans to the test. Let's meet the contenders:

  • Cheap Can: The budget-friendly option for those looking to save a few bucks.
  • No Spill Can: Designed to prevent spills and make fueling easier.
  • SureCan: The star of the show, known for its unique design and features.
  • Eagle Metal Can (Type 1): A more traditional metal can, with a Type 2 version also available.

First Impressions: A Closer Look

What sets these gas cans apart? Let's examine their build quality and key features.

Build Quality and Features Overview

Each can has its own unique design and set of features. Here's a breakdown:

Cheap Can

  • Made in the USA.
  • Features a plastic or nylon flame arrestor that appears to be glued in.
  • Requires two hands to operate the button system.
  • Has a single fill point, with venting through the cap.

Price Breakdown: How Much Do These Cans Cost?

Let's talk money. Here's a quick rundown of the prices for each gas can:

  • Cheap Can: $29.
  • No Spill Can: $49 (5-gallon).
  • SureCan: $69.
  • Eagle Metal Can: $79 (5-gallon), $150 (Type II).

SureCan Variations

Did you know the SureCan also comes in diesel and kerosene versions? They even have a clear can with a spout, perfect for washing your hands on the go.

You can explore a variety of gas cans and other equipment on Main Street Mower's online store .

Flow Rate Face-Off: Speed vs. Convenience

Why Flow Rate Matters

When you're filling up a boat or multiple pieces of equipment, the flow rate of your gas can matters. Waiting around for a slow-pouring can to empty can be a drag. The No Spill can boasts an impressive 3 gallons per minute.

The Flow Rate Test

Time to see how these cans perform under pressure.

Cheap Can

Operating the "Alcatraz mechanism" proved to be a challenge. It takes two hands to press the button, and thumb fatigue quickly sets in. Filling a one-gallon jug felt awkward and tiring.

No Spill Can

The No Spill can claims to fill at 3 gallons per minute, meaning it should fill a gallon in 20 seconds. It definitely felt faster and easier on the hands compared to the Cheap Can. The automatic shut-off feature is a nice touch.

However, the spout's angle might make it tricky to fill some vehicles. On the other hand, it's great for filling smaller engines with precision.

Eagle Metal Can

The funnel is a game-changer when it comes to pouring speed. You can easily monitor the fuel level as you fill.

Be warned: If this can sits in the sun, pressure can build up. If you don't vent it properly, you might get a face full of gasoline.

Despite the potential mess, the metal can pours quickly and efficiently.

SureCan

The SureCan's design allows you to rest it on a surface while filling, which can be incredibly convenient. The flow rate was a bit slower than the others, but the comfortable design makes up for it.

Imagine resting the can on your boat's dock or the armrest of your mower while filling. No more holding heavy cans!

No Spill Can

  • Includes a flame arrestor screen.
  • Features a rear handle and cap cover.
  • Has a visible sight line to easily see the fuel level.

SureCan (Type II)

  • Made in the USA.
  • OSHA safety approved.
  • Features a spring-loaded fill hole for added safety.
  • Equipped with a drop-down hose for convenient filling.

The SureCan stands out with its Type II rating and OSHA approval, highlighting its focus on safety.


Eagle Metal Can (Type I)

  • Has a removable funnel for fast pouring.
  • Some users might find it challenging to attach and remove the funnel.

The Eagle Metal Can is all about speed, thanks to its funnel design that allows for quick fuel dispensing.


Eagle Metal Can (Type 1)

The Leak Test: Spill-Proof Claims Put to the Test

The Importance of Leak-Proofing

Nobody wants a gas can that leaks. It's not just about the smell; it's about safety too. Remember the dreaded gas smell that lingers forever after a spill in your car? Modern gas cans are designed to prevent these kinds of accidents, unlike older models that often lacked proper sealing.

Test Results

Each can was put to the test to see how well it could contain fuel when tipped on it's side:

  • Cheap Can: Held its own without dripping.
  • No Spill Can: Showed no signs of leakage with the cap securely tightened.
  • SureCan: The can did not drip or leak.
  • Eagle Metal Can: Held the fuel, due to it's spring-loaded, rubberized door.

All four cans did a solid job of preventing leaks during the test.

Durability and Comfort: Long-Term Considerations

Durability Ranking

  1. Eagle Metal Can: The most durable option.
  2. No Spill Can: Solid construction and reliable.
  3. SureCan: Durable, but with more parts that could potentially break.
  4. Cheap Can: The least durable of the bunch.

The SureCan does have a replaceable lid, which is a plus.

Comfort Ranking

  1. SureCan: The clear winner in terms of comfort and ergonomics, especially for those with arthritis.
  2. No Spill Can: The rear handle adds to the comfort and ease of use.
  3. Eagle Metal Can: Comfortable, but some angles can be awkward.
  4. Cheap Can: The least comfortable, requiring two hands to operate.

The Mess Factor: Avoiding Gas Spills

Why Avoiding Spills Matters

Avoiding spills keeps your shoes from smelling like gas all day and keeps the environment cleaner.

Spill Potential Ranking

  1. No Spill Can: The shut-off feature minimizes spills.
  2. SureCan: Low spill potential, but the seals are a potential weak point.
  3. Eagle Metal Can: Can be spill-free if you're careful.
  4. Cheap Can: Higher risk of spills due to its design.

The SureCan comes with a 3-year warranty, which is reassuring.

Products Featured In This Blog

The Verdict: Best Overall Value

Final Ranking

  1. No Spill Can: Best overall value, balancing price and features.
  2. SureCan and Eagle Metal Can: Tie for second place. Both are great, but more expensive.
  3. Cheap Can: Last place.

Final Thoughts

Ultimately, the best gas can depends on your individual needs and preferences. Consider what's most important to you – comfort, durability, flow rate, or price – and choose accordingly.

Check out Main Street Mower on social media! You can find them on Facebook and Instagram .

Conclusion

We've taken a close look at four different gas cans, comparing their features, performance, and value. The No Spill can emerged as the winner in terms of overall value, but the SureCan and Eagle Metal Can are also excellent choices depending on your priorities. What has been your experience with these gas cans? Share your thoughts in the comments below. Thanks for reading!

Links to Main Street Mower